Would it surprise you to learn that taxes have nothing to do with logic?
Taxes have nothing to do with logic. Many laws have little to do with logic, but taxes are often completely devoid of it. I can cite hundreds of case where taxes have nothing to do with logic. My favorite involves a fictional astronaut and a salesman. Let us say the astronaut travels a million miles AND PAYS FOR HIS OWN MEALS (humor me please). Can he deduct them?
NO! It may seem that he was away from home overnight, but he never landed away from home. He also was not off duty, for four hours at a time, with a place to sleep. He was never off duty and never had a separate place to sleep.
Now say a salesman tells his wife that he has an overnight business trip. What he really has is a nearby customer and a motel, where he takes his secretary. Can he deduct his meals and motel?
YES! He was away from home overnight, even if he was only a few miles away. He also was off duty for more than four hours, with a place to rest, even if his secretary never let him rest.
That alone should show you that taxes have nothing to do with logic, but there is much more that every CPA knows. How can you tell that taxes have nothing to do with logic? It is easy. All you have to do is learn the number of pages in our income tax laws (around 70,000 and growing fast) and the number of lobbyists. 13,000+ lobbyists get about $3.5 billion a year to make sure that taxes have nothing to do with logic.
Here is my big gun, in my campaign to show why taxes have nothing to do with logic. It is as simple as red and green. What can be simpler than the difference between these colors? Is either color right or wrong? Does either of them have a universal sacred meaning? Is there a LOGICAL difference between them, which makes us behave completely differently when we see them?
Their wavelengths may be different, but that is not why we defy logic in treating them completely differently. YOU GO ON GREEN AND STOP ON RED! Why do you do that? You could say that you do it so you will not get into accidents or get tickets (especially with red light cameras). However, you mainly do it because IT IS THE LAW!
If the most basic traffic law has nothing to do with logic, why would you expect that complex tax laws have anything to do with logic? You can spend a lifetime of hard work, to try to understand taxes, or contact me and let me make them simple. It rarely costs you anything after tax savings.